Comprehensive and collision are the two coverages that pay to fix your own car in Texas, and the split decides which deductible you pay after a hailstorm, a flooded street, a deer strike or a fender-bender.
What do Texas drivers get wrong about comprehensive and collision?
Short answerMany drivers think collision covers any damage to their car and comprehensive means “everything,” when the two split losses by cause and each one leaves the other’s losses unpaid.
The instinct: “Comprehensive sounds like the big one, so the car is covered for anything.”
What’s actually true: collision handles crashes; comprehensive handles nearly everything else that damages or takes the car. A car with collision only gets nothing after a hailstorm; a car with comprehensive only gets nothing after a crash.
What to do instead: check that each vehicle on your declarations page shows both lines, with a deductible you could pay next week.
What is the difference between comprehensive and collision coverage?
Short answerCollision pays for damage to your car from hitting another vehicle or an object, while comprehensive pays when the car is stolen or damaged by something other than a collision, such as hail, flood or an animal.
The Texas Department of Insurance auto guide (updated December 11, 2025) defines them this way: collision coverage pays to repair or replace your car after an accident, and comprehensive (other than collision) coverage pays if your car is stolen or damaged by fire, flood, vandalism or something other than a collision. The Insurance Information Institute adds that collision includes hitting an object and pothole damage, and comprehensive includes falling objects, windstorm, hail and contact with animals such as deer.
| What happened | Coverage that generally pays |
|---|---|
| You rear-end a pickup at a light | Collision (your car); your liability pays for theirs |
| You slide into a guardrail or hit a pothole | Collision |
| Hail, floodwater or a deer strike | Comprehensive |
| The car is stolen, vandalized or catches fire | Comprehensive |
Both protect your car; the liability Texas requires pays others (see Texas car insurance requirements).
Justin leads the Holley Insurance Agency team, which helps Texas families review their home, auto and life coverage before they need it. Meet Justin and the team.
Which Texas car losses fall under comprehensive?
Short answerHail, floodwater, theft, vandalism, fire, flying gravel and animal strikes are all comprehensive losses, and Texas sees every one of them somewhere in the state each year.
TDI’s auto guide lists these as covered if you have comprehensive:
Dents, cracked glass and broken lights after a storm.
Rising water from a hurricane or flash flood.
Deer and other animals on rural roads.
The car stolen from a driveway or lot.
Keyed paint, smashed windows or a burned car.
Chips and cracks from debris on the highway.
The risk shifts with where you park and drive:
| Where you live | The loss to plan for | Which coverage |
|---|---|---|
| Panhandle, North Texas and DFW | Hail on cars parked outside | Comprehensive |
| Gulf Coast and low-lying areas | Hurricane and flash flooding; TDI’s flooded-car tip (October 8, 2025) says comprehensive covers it | Comprehensive |
| Hill Country and rural highways | Deer; TxDOT (October 31, 2024) counts 5 million-plus whitetails in 252 of 254 counties, most active October to December | Comprehensive (collision if you swerve into something) |
| Houston, San Antonio, Austin and other metros | Crashes in traffic, theft and vandalism | Collision for crashes; comprehensive for theft and vandalism |
TDI says a company can’t refuse to renew your policy because of weather damage or hitting an animal. If one storm hits your roof and your car, expect two claims; see wind and hail deductibles for the home side.
When does collision coverage pay, and what if the other driver caused it?
Short answerCollision pays for crash damage to your car whether or not you caused the crash, and it becomes your backup when the at-fault driver’s insurance company won’t pay or can’t pay enough.
III says collision pays for repairs even if you’re at fault, minus your deductible: the one-car slide on a wet ramp, the garage pillar. When the other driver is at fault, you have two paths:
- Claim against their insurance. TDI says you don’t pay a deductible on a claim against another driver’s insurance company.
- Claim against your own collision. If the other company refuses to pay, TDI says you can file with your own company, but you must have collision coverage to do this, and your deductible applies. Your company will usually try to recover the money; III says that if it succeeds, you get your deductible back.
If the other driver had no insurance or too little, see how uninsured motorist coverage in Texas works alongside collision.
How do comprehensive and collision deductibles work?
Short answerEach coverage has its own deductible, the share of each claim you pay before the policy pays the rest, so two claims in one year can mean paying two deductibles.
TDI’s example: on a $1,500 collision claim with a $500 deductible, the company pays you $1,000. III notes comprehensive is usually sold with a separate deductible. On a $3,000 hail repair (calculations, not quotes):
| Comprehensive deductible | You pay | Policy pays (up to) |
|---|---|---|
| $250 | $250 | $2,750 |
| $500 | $500 | $2,500 |
| $1,000 | $1,000 | $2,000 |
Glass is usually a comprehensive claim. III says comprehensive pays to repair a cracked or shattered windshield, and some companies offer the glass portion without a deductible; ask how your policy handles it. TDI says that after three flying-object claims in 36 months, a company can raise your deductible.
How much will comprehensive or collision pay on a totaled car?
Short answerThe most either coverage pays is your car’s actual cash value, meaning what it would cost to replace it minus depreciation, less your deductible, which may be well under what you paid or still owe.
TDI says collision and comprehensive don’t have dollar limits. Companies pay only up to the car’s actual cash value: the cost to replace it, minus depreciation. If repairs would cost close to that value, the company might total the car; TDI says it won’t pay for a new car of the same make and model.
The setup: a Texas family’s financed SUV is totaled in a flash flood. The company values it at $18,000 actual cash value, the comprehensive deductible is $1,000, and the loan payoff is $22,500.
- Comprehensive pays: $18,000 minus the $1,000 deductible, or $17,000.
- Still owed on the loan: $5,500 ($4,500 above the car’s value, plus the deductible).
- Without comprehensive: the full $22,500 loan stays.
Illustration only. Figures are arithmetic, not a quote or a prediction of any claim outcome.
That shortfall is what gap coverage for financed cars is built for. If the valuation seems low, TDI says to be prepared to negotiate and describes an appraisal process for disputes with your own company.
How much do collision and comprehensive cost in Texas?
Short answerNAIC data for 2024 put the Texas average at about $569 a year for collision and $455 for comprehensive per insured car, but your price depends on the car, deductibles, drivers and where you live, so treat these as averages, not quotes.
As of November 2026, that’s the newest company-free figure we could verify. The NAIC divides each coverage’s written premium by insured car-years, warns that the averages don’t reflect the deductibles people choose, and notes that Texas comprehensive car-years are estimated. TDI says these rates are highest for luxury, high-performance and sports cars. See lowering car insurance costs in Texas for safer levers than dropping coverage.
Do you have to carry comprehensive and collision in Texas?
Short answerTexas law doesn’t require either one, but if you still owe money on the car, TDI says your lender will require both, and a lease contract sets its own coverage rules.
According to TDI, if you still owe money on your car, your lender will require you to have collision and comprehensive coverage. If you cancel or lose them, the lender will buy single-interest coverage and add the cost to your loan payment; TDI calls it expensive and says it protects only the lender. Lease contracts spell out their own requirements, so read yours.
When might dropping comprehensive or collision make sense on an older car?
Short answerOnly on a paid-off car you could repair or replace yourself, and the Insurance Information Institute’s rule of thumb is that coverage may not be cost effective once the car is worth less than 10 times its premium.
The Insurance Information Institute suggests considering dropping collision and/or comprehensive on older cars: “If your car is worth less than 10 times the premium, purchasing the coverage may not be cost effective.” Dealers and banks can tell you what a car is worth, III says.
Using NAIC’s 2024 Texas average collision premium as a stand-in for yours: 10 × $569 = $5,690. A hypothetical paid-off $4,000 car falls under that line.
| Your situation | Verdict | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Financed or leased car | Not yours to drop | TDI says the lender requires both and can add costly lender-only coverage |
| Paid off, worth well over 10× the premium | Usually keep | A total loss would cost far more than the coverage |
| Paid off, worth under 10× the premium, cash set aside | Worth reviewing | III’s rule of thumb says coverage may not be cost effective |
| Older car parked outside where hail or flooding hits | Decide each separately | Run the 10× test on each coverage separately |
When we review policies with Texas drivers, the real question is whether losing the car would be an inconvenience or a crisis.
Frequently asked questions
Does comprehensive cover a cracked windshield in Texas?
Generally, yes. The Insurance Information Institute says comprehensive pays to repair a windshield that is cracked or shattered, and the Texas Department of Insurance lists flying gravel among the losses comprehensive pays for. Your comprehensive deductible normally applies, though III notes some companies offer the glass portion without one, so ask how your policy handles glass. TDI says flying-gravel claims can’t be the reason a company refuses to renew your policy, but after three such claims in 36 months, the company can raise your deductible.
Is hitting a deer a comprehensive or a collision claim?
Hitting a deer is generally a comprehensive claim. The Texas Department of Insurance lists hitting an animal among the losses comprehensive pays for, and the Insurance Information Institute notes that collisions with deer are covered under comprehensive. Swerving changes the picture: if you miss the deer and hit a guardrail, a tree or another car, that’s generally a collision with an object or vehicle, which falls under collision coverage. TxDOT warns that many serious crashes happen when drivers swerve to avoid a deer and advises braking firmly and staying in your lane if no traffic is close behind.
Which coverage pays if a hurricane or flash flood ruins my car?
Comprehensive. The Texas Department of Insurance says that if you have comprehensive auto coverage, you’re covered for flood damage to your car. Liability-only coverage pays nothing toward your own car. Your comprehensive deductible applies, and if the repairs would cost close to the car’s value, the company might total it and pay its actual cash value minus the deductible. TDI also says experts recommend having a mechanic look at a flooded car before you try to start it, to avoid more damage.
Do I need collision coverage if the other driver caused the crash?
It still matters. When another driver is at fault, you can file with that driver’s insurance company, and the Texas Department of Insurance says you don’t pay a deductible on a claim against another driver’s insurer. If that company refuses to pay, TDI says you can file with your own company instead, but you must have collision coverage to do it, and you’ll pay your deductible. Your company will usually try to recover the money, and the Insurance Information Institute says that if it succeeds, you get your deductible back.
What does other than collision mean on my declarations page?
It’s another name for comprehensive coverage. The Texas Department of Insurance calls it comprehensive (other than collision) coverage and says it pays if your car is stolen or damaged by fire, flood, vandalism or something other than a collision. TDI’s list of covered losses also includes hail, flying gravel and hitting an animal. On your declarations page it usually appears as its own line for each vehicle, with its own deductible, separate from the collision line. If a vehicle shows no such line, a hailstorm or theft would come out of your pocket.
The Bottom Line
Collision pays to repair or replace your car after a crash with another vehicle or an object, and comprehensive pays for theft and for damage from hail, flood, fire, vandalism, flying gravel or animals. Each has its own deductible, and both pay up to the car’s actual cash value.
Texas law requires neither, but your lender does. Holley Insurance Agency, a licensed Texas agency based in Killeen, will go through each vehicle’s comprehensive and collision lines and deductibles with you, free. Call (254) 669-6522, Mon–Fri 8–5 CT, or see our Texas auto insurance page.
Written by the Holley Insurance Agency team and reviewed by Justin Holley, a licensed Texas insurance agent. Based at 1801 Trimmier Rd, Killeen, serving families across Texas. Figures come from the sources named above and are reviewed quarterly. Coverage descriptions are general: your policy’s forms, endorsements and declarations control. This guide is insurance education, not legal advice. Texas insurance regulator: Texas Department of Insurance.
Last reviewed by the Holley Insurance Agency team on November 17, 2026. Definitions, deductibles, actual cash value, totaled cars, lender rules and nonrenewal limits come from the TDI auto guide (December 11, 2025); flood from TDI’s flooded-car tip (October 8, 2025); glass, coverage details and the 10-times rule from the Insurance Information Institute; hail events from III citing NOAA; deer from TxDOT (October 31, 2024); averages from the NAIC 2024 Average Premium Supplement (September 2026). Dollar examples are arithmetic illustrations, not quotes.